—

Market X-Ray · Toolbox 3

Ratio-Quality Decomposition

A rising ratio is ambiguous. IWM/SPY can rise because small-caps led — or because the S&P fell. This decomposes every structural ratio into what the numerator did versus the denominator, and scores how meaningful the move is: numerator-driven and consistent across horizons = high quality; denominator-driven or one-horizon = low quality, mechanically misleading. Quality is reliability, not direction.

Updated daily · data as of 2026-11-19

Avg quality 44/100 how meaningful, mean
Numerator-driven 36.4% of ratios
Misleading up 3 rising on low quality
Real weakness 5 numerator-driven down

Alerts — misleading strength & real weakness

Misleading strength — Nasdaq Ex-Tech Breadth strong · 100

Nasdaq Ex-Tech Breadth rising mainly because QQQ fell sharply — a mechanically misleading improvement.

  • Ratio +10.6% over 21d
  • Quality score 12/100 (Denominator collapse)
  • Denominator-driven (88% of the move)
Misleading strength — S&P 500 Equal-Weight Breadth strong · 100

S&P 500 Equal-Weight Breadth rising mainly because SPY fell sharply — a mechanically misleading improvement.

  • Ratio +5.5% over 21d
  • Quality score 23/100 (Denominator collapse)
  • Denominator-driven (77% of the move)
Misleading strength — Ex-Tech S&P Breadth strong · 100

Ex-Tech S&P Breadth rising mainly because SPY fell sharply — a mechanically misleading improvement.

  • Ratio +4.7% over 21d
  • Quality score 29/100 (Denominator collapse)
  • Denominator-driven (71% of the move)
Real weakness — Nasdaq Tech vs Ex-Tech strong · 100

Nasdaq Tech vs Ex-Tech falling on QTEC weakness — QTEC dropping faster than QQXT, a high-quality warning.

  • Ratio -13.9% over 21d
  • Quality score 80/100 (numerator-driven)
  • Single-horizon
Real weakness — Large Growth vs Value strong · 100

Large Growth vs Value falling on IWF weakness — IWF dropping faster than IWD, a high-quality warning.

  • Ratio -10% over 21d
  • Quality score 83/100 (numerator-driven)
  • Confirmed across 1d/21d/63d
Real weakness — Semiconductor Leadership strong · 100

Semiconductor Leadership falling on SMH weakness — SMH dropping faster than XLK, a high-quality warning.

  • Ratio -5.7% over 21d
  • Quality score 58/100 (numerator-driven)
  • Confirmed across 1d/21d/63d
Real weakness — Micro-Cap Breadth strong · 100

Micro-Cap Breadth falling on IWC weakness — IWC dropping faster than IWM, a high-quality warning.

  • Ratio -4.1% over 21d
  • Quality score 66/100 (numerator-driven)
  • Confirmed across 1d/21d/63d

Every ratio — decomposed (21-day)

RatioStateQualityDriverNumDenRatioTF
Credit Breadth HYG/LQD ▼ Numerator lag
20
denominator -0.1% +0.3% -0.3% aligned
S&P 500 Equal-Weight Breadth RSP/SPY ▲ Denominator collapse
23
denominator -2.3% -7.4% +5.5% aligned
Small-Cap Breadth IWM/SPY ▲ Defensive improvement
28
denominator -4.4% -7.4% +3.2% mixed
Nasdaq Ex-Top-30 Breadth QNXT/QTOP ▲ Defensive improvement
35
denominator -6.8% -12.4% +6.4% aligned
Ex-Mag-7 Breadth XMAG/SPY ▲ Defensive improvement
35
denominator -4.9% -7.4% +2.7% mixed
Nasdaq-100 Equal-Weight Breadth QQQE/QQQ ▲ Defensive improvement
37
denominator -7.9% -11.1% +3.5% mixed
High-Beta Breadth SPHB/SPLV ▼ Absolute weakness
86
numerator -13.3% +2.3% -15.3% aligned
Consumer Risk Breadth XLY/XLP ▼ Numerator lag
9
denominator +0.3% +3.2% -2.8% aligned
Nasdaq Ex-Tech Breadth QQXT/QQQ ▲ Denominator collapse
12
denominator -1.6% -11.1% +10.6% aligned
Mid-Cap Breadth MDY/SPY ▲ Defensive improvement
28
denominator -3.9% -7.4% +3.7% mixed
Ex-Tech S&P Breadth SPXT/SPY ▲ Denominator collapse
29
denominator -3.1% -7.4% +4.7% aligned
Semiconductor Leadership SMH/XLK ▼ Strong deterioration
58
numerator -19.6% -14.8% -5.7% aligned
Cyclical Breadth XLI/XLU ▼ Absolute weakness
64
numerator -4.1% +2.4% -6.4% aligned
Extended-Market Breadth VXF/SPY ▲ Defensive improvement
33
denominator -5.8% -7.4% +1.7% mixed
Financial Risk Breadth KBE/XLU ▼ Absolute weakness
41
denominator -1.6% +2.4% -3.9% aligned
Software Participation IGV/XLK ▲ Defensive improvement
44
denominator -11.7% -14.8% +3.6% aligned
AI Participation AIQ/XLK ▼ Flat
50
numerator -15% -14.8% -0.2% aligned
Small Growth Breadth IWO/IWN ▼ Strong deterioration
58
numerator -5.2% -3.8% -1.5% aligned
Micro-Cap Breadth IWC/IWM ▼ Strong deterioration
66
numerator -8.3% -4.4% -4.1% aligned
Nasdaq Tech vs Ex-Tech QTEC/QQXT ▼ Strong deterioration
80
numerator -15.3% -1.6% -13.9% mixed
Large Growth vs Value IWF/IWD ▼ Strong deterioration
83
numerator -12.4% -2.6% -10% aligned
Internet Participation FDN/XLK ▲ Defensive improvement
40
denominator -12.3% -14.8% +2.9% mixed

How to read it

Using log returns, ratio return = numerator return − denominator return, so each leg's contribution is exact. The quality score is the numerator's share of the move scaled by how consistently the ratio points the same way across 1, 21 and 63 days — high when the asset we track is genuinely the story, low when the move is a denominator artifact. Misleading strength = a ratio rising on a denominator collapse; real weakness = a ratio falling because the numerator itself is deteriorating, confirmed across horizons.

For information and discussion only — a reading of market internals, not investment advice. Thresholds are uncalibrated pending the planned backtest. Pairs with Breadth-of-Breadth and the Beta-Instability X-Ray.

FAQ · from the current data · as of 2026-11-19

Quick answers

What does Ratio-Quality Decomposition measure?

A rising ratio is ambiguous — it can mean the numerator led (real) or the denominator collapsed (misleading). This decomposes every structural ratio into what the numerator did versus the denominator, and scores how meaningful the move is: numerator-driven and consistent across horizons scores high; denominator-driven or single-horizon scores low.

What is the average ratio quality right now?

As of 2026-11-19, the average quality score across tracked ratios is 44 out of 100, with 36.4% of ratios numerator-driven.

How many ratios are showing misleading strength or real weakness?

As of 2026-11-19, 3 ratios are rising on low quality (misleading strength) and 5 are falling on genuine numerator weakness (real weakness).

How is the quality score calculated?

Using log returns, ratio return equals numerator return minus denominator return, so each leg’s contribution is exact. The quality score is the numerator’s share of the move scaled by how consistently the ratio points the same way across 1, 21 and 63 days — high when the tracked asset is genuinely the story, low when the move is a denominator artifact.